Play-off final chaos heaps shame on Southampton and causes carnage for Hull & Middlesbrough

Middlesbrough's Callum Brittain is challenged by Hull City's Joel Ndala
Middlesbrough's Callum Brittain is challenged by Hull City's Joel NdalaAnna Gowthorpe / Shutterstock Editorial / Profimedia

The 'richest game in football' has been shrouded in controversy this week, after the EFL ruled that Southampton, who were due to play Hull City at Wembley on Saturday, would be expelled from the Championship play-off final.

You can now listen to this article via Spotify.

A decision was reached after the Saints' opponents in the semi-final, Middlesbrough, launched an official complaint regarding a member of Southampton staff allegedly being caught spying at the Teesiders' training ground ahead of the match.

Chaotic lead-up to the play-off final

Their complaint was upheld, throwing the entire lead-up to the final into chaos, given that there would be only a few days for Middlesbrough to ensure their fans got tickets.

Those same fans will also need to work out ways to get to London at the 11th hour, and that's assuming that an appeal, which Southampton are understood to be working on, is allowed to be heard, thus potentially causing further issues.

Aside from their current expulsion, Tonda Eckert's side has been deducted four points from the start of the 2026/27 campaign, putting them at an immediate disadvantage to the other teams in the English second tier.

Although it hasn't been confirmed at the time of writing, Eckert's future with the club surely has to be over, given that he has apparently admitted to being behind the instruction of the filming at Middlesbrough, and also at two other clubs.

Watershed moment for Southampton?

Assuming that any appeal is either thrown out or unsuccessful, which would seem to be the most likely course of action given Eckert's supposed position, it could prove to be a watershed moment for the Saints.

Though the circumstances are different, the club only need to look at the way in which Leicester have plummeted since being relegated along with the Saints last season.

A four-point penalty isn't horrendous, though the lack of finances that Southampton will have been able to utilise were they promoted will mean that players leave the club in order to balance the books.

The subsequent change in dressing room equilibrium and potential quality on the pitch could well have just as far-reaching consequences as those which the Foxes have experienced.

10 years since both Hull and Middlesbrough were in the EPL

Middlesbrough won't care a jot, of course, with manager Kim Hellberg gearing his players up for one of the biggest games of their careers.

It's been 10 years since the club were in the Premier League, which is coincidentally exactly the same period that Hull have also been exiled in the lower reaches of the English football pyramid.

For the first time in a decade, then, one of these two north-east clubs will play in the top-flight once again, and Saturday's epic encounter is almost certain to be settled in normal time.

That's because there have been only six draws between the two teams since March 1991, and that particular game was the last goalless draw in this fixture.

Memories of Windass to fuel the Tigers

Sergej Jakirovic's Hull side might well feel confident of a unique Wembley hat-trick, having been promoted to the top-flight via the Championship play-off final twice before, in 2008/09, and in 2016/17.

The first of those will be fondly remembered for Dean Windass' incredible volley to send his team into the Premier League for the first time in their history.

It's also worth pointing out that momentum and timing at this stage of the season also have a lot to do with which team has enough to grasp their moment of glory.

Hull weren't even in the play-off positions at the start of the Championship's final day, but a win over Norwich, the Tigers' first three points in seven games, saw them climb into the top six at the 11th hour. 

Play-offs a scant reward for Boro

Middlesbrough, on the other hand, looked odds-on for automatic promotion at one stage, despite losing Rob Edwards to Wolves a few months into the season.

Hellberg's studious tenure kept the club on an even keel, but ultimately, they ended the regular season four points short of being able to go up without the drama of the play-offs.

Hull City v Middlesbrough - Recent head-to-head results
Hull City v Middlesbrough - Recent head-to-head resultsFlashscore

The last time that they were in the play-offs was in 2018, and on that occasion, they were beaten at the semi-final stage by Aston Villa.

With Edwards not being able to keep Wolves in the Premier League, it would be with some justification that Boro chairman, Steve Gibson, could delight in passing his former manager on the way back to the promised land.

Who will be the match winner?

Of those players who could prove decisive in the game, Hull will undoubtedly look to either Oli McBurnie (18 goals and seven assists in 41 games) or Joe Gelhardt (15 goals and five assists in 43 games) in the big moments.

For Middlesbrough, Morgan Whittaker's 14 goals meant he finished the season as the club's top scorer, and with seven assists, he had provided the joint most, along with Hayden Hackney, who, like Sunderland's play-off final match winner last season, Tommy Watson, could leave his club directly after the showpiece, as his departure has long been expected.

Jason Pettigrove
Jason PettigroveFlashscore
Wil jij jouw toestemming voor het tonen van reclames voor weddenschappen intrekken?
Ja, verander instellingen